All Star Selections

[KC]

So with URTV10 open and me publicly saying who I thought made it, it's not necessarily final. I would like to at least have a debate here on who we think should be in All-Stars.

The candidates would be Nakomis, Amy, James, Jee, Erika, Sarah, and Janelle. Nathan is not considered since he's already in All-Stars now due to the URTV6 drama.

Make sure to give reasons and most importantly - keep your bias to yourself! All of you are already in All-Stars so I don't want you using this thread to campaign for allies to get in and enemies to stay out.

In any case, the picks I've made, I'm pretty confident with and can't see them changing unfortuantely, since we're missng out on two other great players with them. But I'd still like to hear what you all have to say.

[Alex Coke]

Nakomis- IMO Played the best game, won the most HoH's I believe, and had a great confessional. Hers were fun to read and very detailed. I don't even think this one is up for debate.


Sarah- My favorite Diary Room of the game because she was constantly opening it. I'd say she was the most active player by far and she played an amazing game of playing both sides by throwing practically every competition. It almost worked and she nearly stayed in a very close vote. She was definitely a strategist.


Amy- Both final 2 deserve Allstars. She played a very aggressive game at the end and surprised a lot of people. She was "Mrs. Popular" with everyone at the start and it definitely helped keep her safe most of the game. Great social game. She already has a couple Jurors locked, which shows that. Not to mention all of her confessionals are cute and fun.


James-Probably the most unpredictable person to make it to the final 3. I was certainly surprised to see him there. He survived a close eviction and ALMOST made it to the finals. I think the girls played better games than him, but he did play pretty good and took out the biggest threat in Sarah. His confessionals were also pretty unique with the rhymes, so adding him to the Allstars cast adds some flavor.


Jee- HOLYFKNWOWXDUD. LOL. His game was ten times better than in past seasons. Perhaps aging is a factor, but he definitely deserves Allstars. Housecalls LOVED them some G-UNIT. He played a great competitive game at the end, took out Nathan the biggest liar, and could of easily got the votes at the end. His entire alliance was taken out at the end of the Pre-Jury and he was an underdog for most of the game.




Why I didn't pick them:



Janelle- While I'd love love love to see her make Allstars for my own amusement, and everyone else, her placement really hurts her. I would of picked her over like James if he had gone out at 6th place or something, but she got taken out fast at the Jury. She had a Diary Room but she wasn't anywhere near as active as the 5 Allstars I picked. I think she would deserve it because she was such a huge player in the Pre-Jury stage of this game and probably the biggest threat alongside David. Everyone was targeting her and she slid by winning some competitions. Still, wish she could of made it a bit farther.


Erika- Before you say I'm bias, shove a lemon in your mouth. I still talk to her and believe we're ~past~ our little spat. Having said that, Nakomis hit the reasoning perfectly. Under the radar/invisible to me nearly the whole game. Losing her votes for 5 weeks really hurt her and made her almost invisible. She was a FLOATER, as said by numerous people and managed to make it far for not picking a side. She was often grouped with Danielle. [Floaters aren't really deserving imo] The only good thing about her was her weekly DR updates, but everyone listed above did them too, so she doesn't have anything special but an attitude.





To sum it up, I'm not even sure why you are asking, you had it perfect

[KC]

I'm just curious what everyone thinks. Like I said, me changing them is very doubtful right now. But usually every season I ask HC first and this season I didn't.

[Alex Coke]

Oh I wasn't really asking you lol. I understood why you asked from your first post. I was basically asking a rhetorical question.

[Natalie]

nakomis~ well her diary room is reason enough, i'd say lol, but obviously she played a pretty well rounded game, social and competion wise, and i love that she says what is on her mind.

amy~ she was america's sweet heart this game, until she voted out her friends, she didnt have to win competitions to get where she is, and i would say that is a very strong game.

jee~ he stepped it WAY wayyyy up since urtv 3, like woah. his game was definitely one of the stronger ones, he won competitions like nobodys business.

james ~ well, he did what he wanted this game, i think he was pretty independant, where as the others had a lot more allies, and he still ended up in 3rd place. that is amazing, and deserves AS

sarah~ god, we all know she played an amazing game. socially and competition wise as well. she was the one to watch for, and had she not gone the week andii evicted her she would be winning this season likely. definite allstar.

[Nick]

I'm going to be lame and say I agree with all of you ;D